The Idea…
The NME’S Greatest Albums Of All-Time poll from 1985 jump-started my obsession with popular music, inspiring me to buy dozens of my favourite ever LPs. I learned soon afterwards that the magazine had published an earlier list in 1974, and in those pre-internet days, tried hard to track it down. Eventually, somehow, and from somewhere I can’t quite remember (probably a Back Issues mail order advert), I managed to acquire a tatty old copy. Coming from a definitively post-punk perspective, I found the list somewhat exotic, sometimes horrifying, but always intriguing. I dug it out recently in order to generate some discussion on social media, and – at Philip Downer’s suggestion – agreed to invite a range of music nuts, (writers, musicians, fans) to re-imagine the list today, restricting their choices to albums released before 1st January 1974. The response was surprisingly instantaneous.
Is the ‘canon’ dead?
November 11th: It’s very late in the evening. I should be in bed. I’m rustling through dog-eared scraps of paper pinning scores to roughly alphabeticised lists of albums. I wouldn’t say that I don’t trust computers, but I certainly don’t have confidence that mine will last the pace, so it’s safer this way. I’m on around my fifteenth or sixteenth list (sixty three to go), and already I’m recording the second nomination for Ralf & Florian and the third for Clube da Esquina. I’m thrilled, and for a brief moment believe that, rather than this being an exercise in great folly, what in fact will emerge from this painstaking endeavour will be the greatest list of albums I’ve ever seen. But neither Ralf & Florian nor Clube Da Esquina receive another vote. People are messaging me on Twitter, wanting to amend their selections. I am reassured by their uber-enthusiasm for the task. I’m about 40 votes in before I do a little counting – I can’t stand the suspense – convinced as I am that the tired old ‘canon’ is on its way out. But then I notice that the old favourites have not only started to creep into contention, but have relentlessly and ruthlessly gobbled up and spat out all the quirky curios and cult favourites that have caught my eye, the inclusion of which has made this such a pleasurable process.
And that perhaps is the inevitability of the block vote: there are still some interesting variations here (only 39 survive the original ’74 poll), but the end result is something that looks not unlike the ’95 Mojo poll, and in some ways makes the list of those ranked between 101-200 resemble a ZigZag poll from the mid-70s, peppered as it is with offerings by Jim Sullivan, Bill Fay, The Millenium, White Noise, Silver Apples and Amon Duul 2. As far as the quota ranked at 700 or lower is concerned, it looks a little like a cohort of refugees escaping from a Wire poll, and for some the more interesting things will undoubtedly be happening further down the list.
I make no claim for this to be regarded a definitive list of the Greatest Albums of the period – it could not pretend to be and was never intended to be. Naturally, the people we correspond with on social media often have similar tastes and so while the album which topped the poll may be a moderately surprising choice to some, if you think about the context, it may well be less surprising than you think. I did try to cast the net of contributors as far and wide as possible, and it brought me great satisfaction to read lists which consistently bore witness to the passion, wisdom and broad perspectives of their compilers, each of whom I’m very grateful to, and who are listed at the end of this article.
Anyway, hope you enjoy reading. Let us know what you think. I’m still reeling from Tim Buckley’s Happy Sad ranking a lowly 101st!
[I will post numbers 101-200 at a later date, and perhaps a post-1974 poll may be in order at some point in the future. Watch this space.] (JJ)
100. The Fantastic Expedition of Dillard & Clark (A&M, 1968)
99. Starsailor – Tim Buckley (Straight, 1970)
98. Led Zeppelin IV ( Atlantic, 1971)
97. Something / Anything – Todd Rundgren (Bearsville, 1971)
96. Dark Side Of The Moon – Pink Floyd (Harvest, 1973)
95. The Hangman’s Beautiful Daughter – The Incredible String Band (Elektra, 1968)
94. Journey Into Satchidananda – Alice Coltrane (Impulse, 1971)
93. The United States Of America (Columbia, 1968)
92. American Beauty- The Grateful Dead (Warner Bros, 1970)
91. Aladdin Sane – David Bowie (RCA, 1973)
90. Chelsea Girl – Nico (MGM/Verve, 1967)
89. Small Faces (Decca, 1966)
88. In The Court Of The Crimson King – King Crimson (Island, 1969)
87. Axis: Bold As Love – The Jimi Hendrix Experience (Track, 1967)
86. Future Days – Can (United Artists, 1973)
85. Are You Experienced – The Jimi Hendrix Experience (Track, 1967)
84. Judee Sill (Asylum, 1971)
83. Roxy Music (Island, 1972)
82. John Lennon / Plastic Ono Band (Apple, 1970)
81. Liege & Lief – Fairport Convention (Island, 1969)
80. Arthur Or The Decline & Fall Of The British Empire – The Kinks (Pye, 1969)
79. John Wesley Harding – Bob Dylan (Columbia, 1967)
78. Heart Food – Judee Sill (Asylum, 1973)
77. Bitches Brew – Miles Davis (Columbia, 1970)
76. Safe As Milk – Captain Beefheart & His Magic Band (Buddah, 1967)
75. Who Sell Out – The Who (Track, 1967)
74. Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band – The Beatles (Parlophone, 1967)
73. Trout Mask Replica – Captain Beefheart & His Magic Band (Straight, 1969)
72. Innervisions – Stevie Wonder (Tamla Motown, 1973)
71. Ogden’s Nut Gone Flake – Small Faces (Immediate, 1968)
70. Ege Bamyasi – Can (United Artists, 1972)
69. The Madcap Laughs – Syd Barrett (Harvest, 1970)
68. Berlin – Lou Reed (RCA, 1973)
67. In A Silent Way – Miles Davis (Columbia, 1969)
66. Neu! (Brain, 1972)
65. Maggot Brain – Funkadelic (Westbound, 1971)
64. If Only I Could Remember My Name – David Crosby (Atlantic, 1971)
63. The Doors (Elektra, 1967)
62. Transformer – Lou Reed (RCA, 1972)
61. For Your Pleasure – Roxy Music (Island, 1973)
60. Curtis – Curtis Mayfield (Curtom, 1970)
59. Electric Warrior – T. Rex (Fly, 1971)
58. Let It Bleed – The Rolling Stones (Decca, 1969)
57. Songs Of Leonard Cohen (Columbia, 1967)
56. Gris-Gris: The Night Tripper – Dr. John (Atco, 1968)
55. Histoire De Melody Nelson – Serge Gainsbourg (Philips, 1971)
54. Scott 3 – Scott Walker (Philips, 1969)
53. White Light / White Heat – The Velvet Underground (MGM / Verve, 1967)
52. Electric Ladyland – The Jimi Hendrix Experience (Track, 1968)
51. Otis Blue – Otis Redding (Atco, 1966)
50. The Psychedelic Sounds Of The 13th Floor Elevators (International Artists, 1966)
49. A Love Supreme – John Coltrane (Impulse!, 1965)
48. Abbey Road – The Beatles (Apple, 1969)
47. Kick Out The Jams – MC5 (Elektra, 1969)
46. Tago Mago – Can (United Artists, 1971)
45. Bringing It All Back Home – Bob Dylan (Columbia, 1965)
44. Who’s Next – The Who (Track, 1971)
43. Pink Moon – Nick Drake (Island, 1972)
42. Surf’s Up – The Beach Boys (Brother, 1971)
41. Loaded – The Velvet Underground (Cotillion, 1970)
40. Something Else By The Kinks – The Kinks (Pye, 1967)
39. Buffalo Springfield Again – Buffalo Springfield (Atco, 1967)
38. Sticky Fingers – The Rolling Stones (Rolling Stones, 1971)
37. Easter Everywhere – The 13th Floor Elevators (International Artists, 1967)
36. Exile On Main Street – The Rolling Stones (Rolling Stones, 1972)
35. After The Gold Rush – Neil Young (Reprise, 1970)
34. Five Leaves Left – Nick Drake (Island, 1969)
33. Piper At The Gates Of Dawn – Pink Floyd (EMI, 1967)
32. Bryter Layter – Nick Drake (Island, 1970)
31. The Band (Capitol, 1969)
30. Dusty In Memphis – Dusty Springfield (Atlantic, 1969)
29. Kind Of Blue – Miles Davis (Columbia, 1959)
28. Paris 1919 – John Cale (Reprise, 1973)
27. Younger Than Yesterday – The Byrds (Columbia, 1967)
26. There’s A Riot Goin’ On – Sly & The Family Stone (Columbia, 1971)
25. Blue – Joni Mitchell (Reprise, 1971)
24. The Stooges (Elektra, 1969)
23. The Gilded Palace Of Sin – The Flying Burrito Bros (A&M, 1969)
22. Raw Power – Iggy & The Stooges (Columbia, 1973)
21. Rubber Soul – The Beatles (Parlophone, 1965)
20. Beggars Banquet – The Rolling Stones (Decca, 1968)
19. The Notorious Byrd Bros – The Byrds (Columbia, 1968)
18. The Rise & Fall Of Ziggy Stardust & The Spiders From Mars – David Bowie (RCA, 1972)
17. Fun House – The Stooges (Elektra, 1970)
16. Odessey & Oracle – The Zombies (CBS, 1967)
15. Scott 4 – Scott Walker (Philips, 1969)
14. Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere – Neil Young & Crazy Horse (Reprise, 1969)
13. The Beatles (Apple, 1968)
12. Hunky Dory – David Bowie (RCA/Victor, 1971)
11. No. 1 Record – Big Star (Ardent / Stax, 1972)
10. Highway 61 Revisited – Bob Dylan (Columbia, 1965)
9. The Village Green Preservation Society – The Kinks (Pye, 1968)
8. What’s Going On – Marvin Gaye (Tamla Motown, 1971)
7. The Velvet Underground (MGM, 1969)
6. Blonde On Blonde – Bob Dylan (Columbia, 1966)
5. Astral Weeks – Van Morrison (Warner Bros, 1968)
4. Pet Sounds – The Beach Boys (Capitol, 1966)
3. Revolver – The Beatles (Parlophone, 1966)
2. The Velvet Underground & Nico (MGM / Verve, 1967)
1. Forever Changes – Love (Elektra, 1967)
Many Thanks to all who agonised and sweated blood before submitting their contributions to the poll:
Camilla Aisa, Andy (Birmingham ’81), Michael Bailey (Soft Hearted Scientists), Caroline Binnie, Nick Blakey (Underground Jukebox), Stephen Boyd, Holly Boyd, Mark Brend, Johnny Browning, Colin Brunton, Robert Century, Rob Chapman, Si Cole, Stuart Cosgrove, Jon Dennis, Mick Derrick, John Dickie, Philip Downer, Spender Downes, Vincent Driscoll, Matthew Edwards, Russell Elder, Liam Elliott, Matt Elliott, Declan Flanagan, Paul Gallagher, Gary (Captain Howdy), Ash Grace, Andrew Hall, Oliver Hawthorn, Greg Healey, Mark Hillier, Robert Hodgens, Sophie Jay, Johnnie Johnstone, Peter Johnstone, Allan Jones, Harris King, Graham Kingsbury, Blair Liddell, Paul Lowman, Gary Mackenzie, Gavin Martin, Stewart May, Stephen McAuley, Ryan McCullough, Grant McPhee, Fiona McQuarrie, John Medd, Andy Miller, Rob Morgan, Tony Mulraney, Jason Myles, Jeremy Neal, Kris Needs, Ingrid Neimanis (Neon Brambles), Thomas Patterson, Nick Portnell, Johnny Purcell, Mark Raison, Peter Rice, Don Richmond, Matt Rogers, Marco Rossi, Martin Ruddock, Chris Sawle, Jason Spence, Arthur David Spota, Theo Stockman, David Tanner, Huw Thomas, Daniel Thompson, James Timoney, Terry Tochel, Sughosh Varadarajan, Denis Version, Judah Warsky, Stevie Watt, Sandy Wishart.
Appendix: 101-200
101. Happy Sad – Tim Buckley
102. Talking Book- Stevie Wonder
103. Countdown To Ecstasy – Steely Dan
104. Goodbye & Hello – Tim Buckley
105. Gene Clark & The Godsin Brothers – Gene Clark
106. Hot Buttered Soul – Isaac Hayes
107. Cosmo’s Factory – Creedence Clearwater Revival
108. Songs Of Love & Hate – Leonard Cohen
109. Songs Of Innocence – David Axelrod
110. The Man Who Sold The World – David Bowie
111. 5D (Fifth Dimension) – The Byrds
112. Pieces Of A Man – Gil Scott-Heron
113. Os Mutantes – Os Mutantes
114. GP – Gram Parsons
115. New York Tendaberry – Laura Nyro
116. Here Come The Warm Jets – Eno
117. Quadrophenia – The Who
118. Every Picture Tells A Story – Rod Stewart
119. Bookends – Simon & Garfunkel
120. From Elvis In a Memphis – Elvis Presley
121. Just Another Diamond Day – Vashti Bunyan
122. Help! – The Beatles
123. I Never Loved A Man (The Way I Loved You) – Aretha Franklin
124. All Things Must Pass – George Harrison
125. Crosby Stills & Nash – Crosby Stills & Nash
126. Giant Steps – John Coltrane
127. Bill Fay – Bill Fay
128. New York Dolls – New York Dolls
129. Aerial Ballet – Nilsson
130. Nashville Skyline – Bob Dylan
131. Head – The Monkees
132. Begin – The Millenium
133. Moby Grape – Moby Grape
134. New Morning – Bob Dylan
135. Disraeli Gears – Cream
136. Clear Spot – Captain Beefheart & The Magic Band
137. Led Zeppelin III – Led Zepoelin
138. Bert Jansch – Bert Jansch
139. Silver Apples – Silver Apples
140. Nancy & Lee – Nancy Sinatra & Lee Hazlewood
141. Meddle – Pink Floyd
142. Original Soundtrack – The Harder They Come
143. Mott – Mott The Hoople
144. Oar – Alexander ‘Skip’ Spence
145. A Wizard A True Star – Todd Rundgren
146. The Marble Index – Nico
147. An Electric Storm – White Noise
148. Their Satanic Majesties Request – The Rolling Stones
149. Clube Da Esquina – Milton Nascimento / Lo Borges
150. Roots – Curtis Mayfield
151. Live At The Apollo – James Brown
152. Scott – Scott Walker
153. Aftermath – The Rolling Stones
154. Headquarters – The Monkees
155. Sunflower – The Beach Boys
156. Blue Afternoon – Tim Buckley
157. Walk Away Renee / Pretty Ballerina – The Left Banke
158. Love – Love
159. Tim Hardin 1 – Tim Hardin
160. Closing Time – Tom Waits
161. Present Tense – Sagittarius
162. Basket Of Light – Pentangle
163. Tim Hardin 2 – Tim Hardin 2
164. Underground- The Electric Prunes
165. Watertown – Frank Sinatra
166. Band On The Run – Wings
167. Sketches Of Spain – Miles Davis
168. Wee Tam & The Big Huge – The Incredible String Band
169. Surrealistic Pillow – Jefferson Airplane
170. Sunshine Superman – Donovan
171. Bridge Over Troubled Water – Simon & Garfunkel
172. Between The Buttons – The Rolling Stones
173. Live At The Star Club – Jerry Lee Lewis
174. Gonna Take A Miracle – Laura Nyro & Labelle
175. Back To The World – Curtis Mayfield
176. Solid Air – John Martyn
177. Dixie Chicken – Little Feat
178. Here’s Little Richard – Little Richard
179. Face To Face – The Kinks
180. Mr. Tambourine Man – The Byrds
181. Lady Soul – Aretha Franklin
182. Moondance – Van Morrison
183. A Hard Days Night – The Beatles
184. UFO – Jim Sullivan
185. Unicorn – Tyrannosaurus Rex
186. Pawn Hearts – Van Der Graaf Generator
187. Spooky Two – Spooky Tooth
188. Requiem For An Almost Lady – Lee Hazlewood
189. Yeti – Amon Duul 2
190. Goats Head Soup – The Rolling Stones
191. Moondog – Moondog
192. Space Ritual – Hawkwind
193. Superfly – Curtis Mayfield
194. SF Sorrow – The Pretty Things
195. Various Artists – Nuggets (Original Artyfacts From The First Psychedelic Era, 1965-68)
196. Aqualung – Jethro Tull
197. Lola Versus Powerman and the Moneygoround Vol. 1 – The Kinks
198. Deja VU – Crosby Stills Nash & Young
199. In The Land Of Grey And Pink – Caravan
200. Call Me – Al Green
……………………………………….
‘One Vote Wonders’
Kafunta – PP Arnold
I’m Gonna Miss You – The Artistics
…Starring Rosi- Ash Ra Tempel
Afro-Harping – Dorothy Ashby
Love Cry – Albert Ayler
Prelude To… – Barbara & Ernie
Acid – Ray Barretto
Fetus – Franco Battiato
Triangle – The Beau Brummels
The Time Has Come – Anne Briggs
As I Am – Chris Britton
In Sommerhausen – Marion Brown
Half-Baked – Jimmy Campbell
Bobby Charles – Bobby Charles
Stimulus – Keith Christmas
Love Is Blue – Claudine
Down Another Road – Graham Collier Sextet
Of The People, By The People, For The People – The Common People
India – Gal Costa
Born Robert Waldon Cassotto – Bobby Darin
The Psychedelic Moods Of… – The Deep
I’m A Loser – Doris Duke
El Topo – Original Soundtrack (Jodorowsky)
Yellow Princess – John Fahey
Est Folle – Brigitte Fontaine
Genuine Imitation Life Gazette- The Four Seasons
Young Gifted & Black – Aretha Franklin
Local Gentry – Bobbie Gentry
One Flight Up – Dexter Gordon
…Sings of Mixed-Up Hearts – Lesley Gore
Folk, Blues & Beyond – Davy Graham
Indian War Whoop – The Holy Modal Rounders
Father Of Folk Blues – Son House
Keep On Pushing – The Impressions
Gypsy People – Jan & Lorraine
El Aparecido – Victor Jara
Bless Its Pointed Little Head – Jefferson Airplane
Is It Because I’m Black – Syl Johnson
July – July
Faintly Blowing – Kaleidescope
Volunteered Slavery – Roland Kirk
That Bad Eartha – Eartha Kitt
Kraftwerk 2 – Kraftwerk
Love Is Here And Now You’re Gone – Tami Lynn
Stargazer – Shelagh McDonald
Danses et Rythmes de la Turquie – Les Mogol
Montage – Montage
Morgen – Morgen
Search For The New Land – Lee Morgan
The Lonely Surfer – Jack Nitzsche
Rehearsals For Retirement- Phil Ochs
Osmium – Parliament
These Things Too – Pearls Before Swine
In Search Of Amelia Earhart – Plainsong
Message Dubwise – Prince Buster
Paix – Catherine Ribeiro & Alpes
Ask Me No Questions – Bridget St. John
Saint Steven – Saint Steven
Sainte Anthony’s Fyre – Sainte Anthony’s Fyre
Three Ragas – Ravi Shankar
The Further Adventures Of Charles Westover – Del Shannon
Philosophy Of The World – The Shaggs
The Spice Of Life – Marlena Shaw
Lux Aeterna – William Sheller
Serenade For A Soul Sister – Horace Silver Quintet
A Harvest Of Gentle Clang – Patrick Sky
Karyobin & The Imaginary Birds That Live In Paradise – Spontaneous Music Ensemble
Cosmic Tones For Mental Therapy – Sun Ra & His Myth Science Arkestra
Dreams – Gabor Szabo
Toussaint – Allen Toussaint
Think Pink – Twink
Double Seven – The Upsetters
Dino Valente – Dino Valente
L’Enfant Assassin des Mouches – Jean Claude Vannier
Vergogna Schifosi – Original Soundtrack (Ennio Morricone)
Bright Phoebus – Lal & Mike Waterson
Moanin’ The Blues – Hank Williams
Someday Man – Paul Williams
Emergency! – The Tony Williams Lifetime
Peter Wyngarde – Peter Wyngarde
Grande Liquidacao – Tom Zé
D ‘yer know, there’s not a bad record in the hundred…a bit surprised at the preponderance go stooges at the top…maybe im out of sync…..glad to see big star so high….
LikeLike
Yeah, everyone voted for No.1 Record. I think Radio City got two votes, and Sister Lovers was after ‘74, so that kind of worked in their favour.
LikeLike
If you’re a listophile (like myself) then Julian’s rock lists (http://www.rocklistmusic.co.uk/) is an awesome resource. Also, I totally agree that Happy Sad should be way higher than 101!
LikeLike
Missed Family – Music In A Dolls House, Soft Machine, vol. 1 and 2 and Moby Grape – 69.
LikeLike
Missed: Family – Music In A Dolls House, Soft Machine – vol. 1 and 2 and Moby Grape – 69.
LikeLike
Makes you realise what a wealth of good material was recorded before `74.
LikeLike
Where the hell is Yoko Ono’s Fly?
LikeLike